Wrong Recipes

I was trying to make shawarma beef for my husband's dinner. But I think I choose wrong recipe from the Internet. Husband said that the taste was really different that the other shawarma that I made for him few months ago. Which recipe was that? I did not remember anymore. I searched that recipe from Internet as well but I forgot which one it was. Husband said that I should keep recipes that I have tried so I don't have to search and choose the wrong one next time. Hm... maybe I should listen to him this time.